Warning: This article contains spoilers from the American Idol season 23 finale!
John Foster may not have wonAmerican Idolseason 23, but he’s now revealing if he knew the results ahead of time. John easily sailed into the finale after becoming one of the frontrunners early on in the competition. During theAmerican Idolseason 23finale,he sang “Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue (The Angry American)” and “Take Me Home, Country Roads,” which helped him land in the Top 2 alongside Jamal Roberts, which meant Breanna Nix was eliminated in third place. John then sang “Tell That Angel I Love Her” butlost to Jamal in the end.
American Idol’s John Foster revealed whether he saw the winner’s name on Ryan Seacrest’s card just before the big announcement.
TV Insiderasked John whether he saw the winner’s name on Ryan Seacrest’s card just before the host announced the 2025 champion. “I was in a total blur. I knew I was at peace with being runner-up. Jamal is such an incredible performer. I was at peace. I really was. It’s a true honor to be runner-up.” Since he said he was in a “blur,” it sounds like he might not have registered that Jamal’s name was on the card, thoughhe acknowledged he “barely” saw the name. Multiple fans on social media were convinced he was spoiled.
What John Foster Looking Over At Card Means For American Idol
John Foster Isn’t The Only Idol Finalist To Be Spoiled
With the camera on John and Jamal as Ryan made his typically dramatic pause right before announcing the winner, viewers could see that John looked over at the card, then looked over at Jamal’s face when the latter’s name was finally revealed. Even though John claimed he “barely” registered the name on the card,the slight change in his expression did make it seem like he saw Jamal’s name. There have been times in the past when one of the Top 2 finalists has seen the winner’s card ahead of time, either in those seconds before it’s announced or backstage.
The most famous moment when a finalist was spoiled happened during theAmerican Idolseason 2 finale when Ryan had the winner’s card in his dressing room andClay Aiken saw that Ruben Studdard would soon be declared the new American Idol. When Clay and Ruben were waiting on stage for the big reveal, Clay purposefully stared at Ruben because he wanted to see the Alabama resident’s face when he was crowned the champion. There were some instances after that when Ryan had no name written on the card in order to prevent any contestant from being spoiled.
Our Take On How Ryan Seacrest Holds Winner’s Envelope
Ryan Seacrest Needs A Better Solution
Ryan is one of the best hosts in the industry, so it’s surprising he still hasn’t learned how to hold the card during his dramatic pause. Either he should directlyface theAmerican Idolfinalistsso there’s no chance they can see, or he needs to stand farther apart from the contestants instead of directly next to them. After this latest debacle,it seems Ryan needs to go back to those years when there was no name written on the card and he was fed the winner’s name through his earpiece. That way, no one is spoiled onAmerican Idol.
American Idol
Cast
American Idol is a revival of the groundbreaking television series that redefined the music competition genre. Premiering on July 31, 2025, it features a new generation of contestants vying for a life-changing recording contract, under the guidance of a panel of renowned judges.
