The SopranosandThe Wireare arguably two ofthe greatest TV dramas of all time, but one is slightly better than the other. The shows have similarities, as both are crime-focused and boast unforgettable characters, butthe first major difference is in their perspectives.The Sopranosis mostly centered on a villain, whileThe Wirepresents both sides of a narcotics operation.
WhereasThe Sopranosis a character study focusing on the mob boss Tony Soprano,The Wireis a police procedural with a difference, diving deeper into societal issues like inequality. BothThe WireandThe Sopranoshave given us some ofthe greatest TV episodes of all time, but one of the two shows has been more consistent in its quality.
The Sopranos Was More Consistent Start To Finish Than The Wire
Though The Wire Gave Us More Iconic Characters
The Sopranosdid not have a bad season, and manyepisodes ofThe Sopranosare considered masterpieces. The show introduced us to the terrifying Tony and his changing relationships with his family, meaning that we got to see his children grow up onscreen. This does not always work for dramas, butThe Sopranosis a character study, and the approach only made the show better.
The Sopranoscharacters were generally morally ambiguous, and this has allowed viewers to continue analyzing them years after the finale.
WhileThe Wireis mostly consistent, season 2 was polarizing for many viewers, with a drastic shift in both tone and location. The Greek smuggling ring was not as popular as other established plots for the show, and was seen as a general low point. While the show finished on a strong note, season 5 was also a slight step down in quality.
The Sopranoscharacters were generally morally ambiguous, and this has allowed viewers to continue analyzing them years after the finale. That said,The Sopranoswas centered on Tony, whileThe Wirehas given us several iconic characters.The best characters inThe Wirechallenge stereotypes and are compelling to watch, with Omar Little being one of the greatest in the show.
The Sopranos Ending Was Polarizing, But It Made The Show Unforgettable
The greatest episode ofThe Sopranosis arguably “Pine Barrens,” a bottle episode that became one ofthe highest-rated TV episodes of all time. On the other hand,The Wire’s episode “Final Grades” was both uplifting and tragic, embodying the themes of the show.BothThe SopranosandThe Wirehad moments of genius, butThe Sopranosjust beatsThe Wirewith “Pine Barrens.”
Rotten Tomatoes critics' rating
Rotten Tomatoes audience rating
6
92%
96%
5
95%
The endings toThe SopranosandThe Wireare almost polar opposites, withThe Wiregiving closure andThe Sopranosbeing open-ended.The Wireends with a montage showing the fates of the main characters, whileThe Sopranos' finale was extremely controversial, cutting to black. This ending might have been divisive, but it ensuredThe Sopranoswould stay memorable forever.
