American Idolseason 23 has been a total snoozefest so far, putting me to sleep with every episode, but I think thata night without ballads could energize the show, and really make the finalists shine.American Idolseason 23 welcomed back host Ryan Seacrest, along with judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. However, for the first time in the ABC era of the show, there was a shakeup at the judging table asAmerican Idolseason 4 winner Carrie Underwood took Katy Perry’s place.
American Idolseason 23has now narrowed down its contestants to its Top 10 finalists. They includeThunderstorm Artis, John Foster, Canaan James Hill, Kolbi Jordan, Josh King, Slater Nalley, Breanna Nix, Mattie Pruitt, Jamal Roberts, and Gabby Samone. They’re all incredibly talented, but I’ve found myself very bored during the episodes. I think this is because there have been hardly any upbeat performances throughout the competition so far. The finalists have been relying on ballads to showcase their vocals, but I think a night without ballads could reinvigorate the show.
The American Idol Top 10 Finalists Have Sung Too Many Ballads
They Haven’t Taken Advantage Of The Theme Nights
So far,American Idolseason 23 has had three theme nights, including Songs of Faith, Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, and IconicAmerican IdolMoments. Although the finalists gave some extraordinary performances, many of them were ballads, which became very tedious to watch and listen to. On Rock & Roll Hall of Fame night, Carrie lamented that the contestants weren’t rocking out, and I agreed with her completely.
Whilea few of the contestants sang some upbeat songs, including Filo’s “With a Little Help from My Friends,” Mattie’s “Piece of My Heart,” John’s “Jailhouse Rock,” Jamal’s “Shout,” and Josh’s “The Longest Time,“the episode concluded with several balladsincluding,Thunderstorm’s “Fire and Rain,“Gabby’s “Saving All My Love for You,” Breanna’s “Open Arms,” Ché’s “It’s a Man’s Man’s Man’s World,” and Slater’s “Your Song.”
In the midst of all of those ballads, Kolbi sang, “You’re All I need to Get By,” but there were already too many slow songs in a row in order to catch my attention. In addition,it was the third time that “It’s a Man’s Man’s Man’s World” was performed in full during the season, with Ché singing it after Amanda Barise and Mattie. I don’t understand why the show would allow three contestants to sing the same song in such a short period of time, especially because it’s a ballad that doesn’t do much to showcase the contestants' personalities.
During IconicAmerican IdolMoments Night, every single contestant sang ballads. Although their performances were impressive, after two nights in a row of that many ballads, I was exhausted by the end of the show. On both Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Night and IconicAmerican IdolMoments Night, the contestants could’ve chosen more upbeat songs instead of so many ballads.
The possibilities from the night’s mentor alone, Fantasia Barrino, included “Proud Mary,” “Think, “Something to Talk About,” “Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I’m Yours),” “I Heard It Through the Grapevine,” “Get on Your Feet,” “Crazy Little Thing Called Love,” “Knock on Wood,” “Holding Out for a Hero,” and “Chain of Fools,” among others. I don’t understand why none of the Top 10 finalists took advantage of such an incredible list of songs. I really hope that, during Women in Music Night,mentor Miranda Lambert, who’s known for her sassy personality, encouragesthe Top 10 finalists to choose some uptempo songs that showcase a whole new side to their personalities.
American Idol Used To Have More Upbeat Performances
Contestants Showcased Their Vocals With More Than Just Ballads
I’ve been watchingAmerican Idolsince season 1, and some of my favorite performances have been upbeat songs that weren’t ballads. Season 1 winner Kelly Clarkson was known for her bubbly performances, including her classic, “Stuff Like That There.” I also enjoyed season 5 winner Taylor Hicks' exciting performances of songs such as “Takin' It to the Streets,” “Living for the City,” “Play That Funky Music,” “Jailhouse Rock,” and “Try a Little Tenderness.” His dancing always made me smile.
In addition,American Idolseason 5 runner-up Katharine McPhee often wowed the crowdwith her uptempo songs and dancing in performances such as “Since I Fell for You,” “Think,” “Bringing Out the Elvis,” “Black Horse and the Cherry Tree,” and “Hound Dog/All Shook Up.” They made it to the final two of their season becausethey were so much fun to watch, and I always looked forward to seeing what they’d do next.
Taylor and Katharine are just two examples of people who really brought star quality to the show by taking chances with songs other than ballads now and then. Of course, they also sang some gorgeous ballads during their time onAmerican Idol, butthey were much more versatile than today’s contestants.
American Idolseems to have forgottenthat part of its purpose is to entertain viewers, and not just showcase vocals. Although I know that the performances are technically great, I find it very tiresome to watch the contestants singing ballad after ballad, as though that’s the only way to prove that they’re good performers. It seems a bit self-indulgent, when they should be focusing on crowd-pleasing performances. Being an entertainer also requires singers to work the crowd, get them involved, and maybe even dance a bit.It’s not as though the themes haven’t allowed for that.
American Idol Should Have A Night Without Ballads
The Show Should Challenge The Finalists To Move Out Of Their Comfort Zones
I know thattheAmerican IdolTop 10 finalists could really benefit from the show forcing them not to sing ballads. They all have great personalities that just aren’t coming through each week. I want to see them move out of their comfort zones and do something fun and exciting to enhance their phenomenal performances. However,American Idolmust enforce the theme.
DuringAmerican Idolseason 22, I think that the show was trying to do this with their Songs That Make You Want to Dance Night, butEmmy Russell turned Walk the Moon’s “Shut Up and Dance"into a ballad, and even sat at the piano during her performance. I wanted to see her come out of her shell, but it didn’t happen.However, ifAmerican Idoldevoted a night to songs that weren’t ballads, then the contestants wouldn’t be able to do this.
As anAmerican Idolfan since season 1, I really miss seeing contestants take chances on the show by singing songs other than ballads. I think that the show should have a theme night during which the finalists aren’t allowed to sing them. It would breathe new life into the show and make it much more entertaining to watch. I want to be able to watch an entire episode without feeling like I’m being sung to sleep.American Idolseason 23 needs to put the ballads to bed.
American Idolairs Sundays and Mondays at 8 p.m. EDT on ABC.
