The long-awaited reveal of90 Day: The Last Resortstar Josh Weinstein’s new love interest was finally revealed on the latest Tell All: Josh is datingnone other than the sister of90 Day Fiancéstar Elizabeth “Libby” Castravet, Jen Potthast. Jen is no stranger to90 Day Fiancéfans, as she appeared on90 Day Fiancéand90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever Afterwhile her sister,Libby, and brother-in-law, Andrei Castravet, navigated the K1 visa process. Libby’s family played a central role in her time on reality TV, so viewers got to know Jen well.

Jen was previously married to radio personality Orlando Davis. They have two daughters. Josh had teased that he was dating someone new and even said it was someone familiar to90 Day Fiancéfans, so speculation about the identity of Josh’s mystery woman was rampant up until the reveal.I had seen rumors Jen was Josh’s new girlfriend, so when she made a video appearance on the last90 Day: The Last ResortTell All, it wasn’t a surprise to me.

90 Day Fiance star Jenn Potthast and Josh Weinstein with both smiling with neon accents in background

Josh Weinstein’s Mystery Girlfriend Revealed (She’s Not New To 90 Day Fans)

The Cast Was Surprised To See Jen

Jen was revealed to be Josh’s new girlfriendduring a segment on the90 Day: The Last ResortTell All. As host Shaun Robinson asked Josh whether he was dating again, he revealed he was. Josh didn’t call her his girlfriend, but he said there was someone in his life that he “liked” and that they’d been hanging out.

Shaun surprised the rest of the cast when she announced that they were going to video in Josh’s new love interest, and she teased that it was someone we’d recognize from another couple’s90 Day Fiancéjourney. When the video cuts to Jen sitting in what appears to be her home, the rest of the people on the Tell All stage look shocked. Rob Warne spoke for us all when he said:

90 Day the Last Resort Series Poster-1

“That’s what’s her name’s sister, isn’t it?”

Josh Has Teased New Girlfriend For Months

Fan Accounts Named Jen As Josh’s Girlfriend

A few months ago,90 Day Fiancéfan accounts and other publications startednaming Jen as Josh’s possible romantic interest. On March 4, the Instagram accounttherealitytvmessnamed Jen as Josh’s potential new romantic partner. Comments on that video pointed out that the video wasn’t recent, which made sense when Josh and Jen revealed on the Tell All that they’ve actually been family friends for years.

Speculation about Jen and Josh’s relationship continued until Josh and Jen confirmed it on the Tell All. Natalie Mordovtseva, Josh’s ex, who appeared on90 Day: The Last Resortwith him, seemed stunned when Jen’s image appeared on the screen. Natalie and Josh had been in an on-again, off-again relationship for years, butJosh’s refusal to put a label on it caused their relationship to suffer. They went onThe Last Resortas a last-ditch attempt to save their relationship, butJosh and Natalie decided to split.

Josh’s New Girlfriend Videos In For Tell All

Jen Seemed Very Comfortable On Camera

Jen is no stranger to reality TV cameras. Her family was featured on90 Day Fiancéwhen her younger sister, Libby, fell in love with Andrei and the two decided to get married. The show documented their process of dealing with cultural differences, family issues, work struggles, and more. Libby and Andrei are still together and are the parents of Eleanor and Winston.

Josh’s New Girlfriend Throws Barbs At Natalie

Jen Shaded Natalie

After Jen settled into her portion of the Tell All, she explained she and Josh had a history because her mom and sister Libby used to work for him. Josh is a talent agent, and Libby dabbled in acting, so their storylines add up.Josh and Jen had only reconnected recently, and their friendship turned romantic. It’s still new, so they weren’t labeling it yet, but Jen said Josh made her happy. When Shaun asked Jen what she thought about his time on the show with Natalie, Jen didn’t hold back. She called Natalie “crazy” and said she should have known better.

“Clearly the guy is not into you, like hello. It was never going to be creating a family with Josh and having his kids. I mean, if she didn’t know that, she’s, you know, crazy.”

Natalie took the high road. She said she wished Josh and Jen the best, and said she hopes they don’t think of her and Josh’s relationship as they embark on their own. Natalie began to tear up, but she maintained she was happy for Josh and Jen.

90 Day: The Last ResortTell All part 5 airs on April 28 on TLC.