The recent engagement of twoMarried at First Sightalums from different seasons proves that the hit reality show does not need the experts. The experts' role inMarried at First Sightis to sort through the organic applicants and recruited participants and make matches based on compatibility factors.
They are supposed to consider cultural backgrounds, physical appearance preferences, socio-economic factors, and participants' hopes and goals for the future. The experts are also meant to guide the couples on the eight-week-long journey to decision day, and counsel them when things start to derail.

However, theMAFSexperts have not done a good job in the over 10 years the show has been running seasons, as the couples' success rate is very low. In the last 18 seasons, there’s only been an 18.75% success rate. This is not a good look for the “experts'” abilities, and that is being underscored even more by a recent cross-season development.
Steve Stayed After Decision Day & Mindy Did Not
Mindy Shiben married Zach Justice inMAFSseason 10, but Zach clearly wasn’t marriage material. Zach flirted with MIndy’s friends, told Mindy he wasn’t attracted to her, and was on the fence about commitment. The pair said no to staying married come decision day.
Steve Moy married Noi Phommasak tied the knot inMarried at First Sightseason 14in Boston.The pair consummated their marriageand had good outward chemistry, but Noi’s immature behavior, especially on social media, coupled with her hyper-critical lens of Steve led the pair astray. While they said yes on decision day, they sought divorce within six months. Noi blasted Steve on social media, while Steve went the more tasteful route about their split.
Mindy & Steve Are Now Engaged
They’ve Been Together Over Two Years
In a shocking turn of events for the formerMAFScast members, Mindy and Steve got together more than two years ago afterMindy slid into Steve’s DMs.The pair have had an exciting and loving relationship, and love to both share a united outward front.
That front was ever-present in a recent post fromSteve, sharing that he had proposed to Mindy and she said yes.
The MAFS Experts Have Not Been Doing Their Jobs
MAFS Cast Are Matching Themselves
With Steve and Mindy matching themselves after being paired with incompatible people on the show originally, it negates the need for the experts. Moreover, inMAFSseason 18 in Chicago, two of the participants,Madison Myers and David Trimble, carried on an illicit affair and matched themselves, further proving thatthe experts can’t get it right.
Season 16’s Domynique Kloss also attempted to match herself with Gil Cuero, so there is a pattern here withinMarried at First Sight.