The director of theI Know What You Did Last Summerreboot explains why one original cast member did not appear. The slasher horror franchise returns this year, as a new group of friends is stalked by a hook-wielding killer who knows about a dark secret from their past. This installment is directed by Jennifer Kaytin Robinson.

The reboot’s cast is full of a lot of new faces. This includes Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders, Tyriq Withers, and Jonah Hauer-King. However, theI Know What You Did Last Summercastalso includes Freddie Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt returning to their lead roles, as well as some surprise cameos.

Jennifer Love Hewitt as Julie James, Sarah Michelle Gellar as Helen Shivers, Ryan Phillippe as Barry Cox, and Freddie Prinze Jr. as Ray Bronson in the car in the beginning of I Know What You Did Last Summer

Now, Robinson explains toPeoplewhy Ryan Phillippe did not return inI Know What You Did Last Summer. The writer-director explained thatincluding Phillippe’s character “just got to be too much,“so Barry Cox was relegated to a shoutout.

However, she did say that “there is a very fun way to integrate Ryan into a sequel.” Check out the full quote from Robinson below:

I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025) Official poster)

It just got to be too much. We have a Barry Cox mention. He gets a shout-out. But, yeah, it started to feel like too many ideas. But it is not for a lack of love of Ryan — he is amazing. And I do think there is a very fun way to integrate Ryan into a sequel that I hope happens.

What This Means For I Know What You Did Last Summer

The Second Film Needs To Be Made For Barry To Return

Barry Cox’s relegation to name-drop only is a somewhatunexpected facet ofI Know What You Did Last Summer. Though not everyone was featured in the promotional material,several original cast members came back for the movie.

The reboot is full of references to the original, so it makes sense why Robinson would’ve come up with an idea for Phillippe to return. Had there been room, he could’ve very well appeared in a dream sequence, or even some kind of de-aged flashback. He could also return in the future, though this iscontingent upon whether the movie actually gets awarded a sequel.

So far, the prospect of more movies is decent.I Know What You Did Last Summermade $13 million in its domestic opening, which is almost as much as the original did in the same timeframe. If it continues its momentum, it could be considered a successful legacy sequel, especially since its budget is a mere $18 million.

Our Take On Barry Cox’s Return To I Know What You Did Last Summer

It makes sense why Robinson would fear the slasher becoming too overstuffed. Already,the film shows a fraught relationship between Ray and Julie, two of the original characters. It needed ample time to unpack their story.

I Know What You Did Last Summerhad to manage this, all while fleshing out its new characters. This is a delicate balance to strike and indeed could have felt overwhelming with Barry included. If all goes well with the movie’s run, however,we could see more from Phillippe in this rebooted horror series.